Choosing between a rubber roof vs metal roof can feel like a big decision, but understanding your property’s needs will make the choice easier. Both are very smart choices for Virginia’s climate, but they each work best in certain scenarios. A rubber roof is ideal for flat roofs, whereas metal roofs are better suited for sloped roofs. Taking aesthetics, budget, and structural design into consideration, the experts at Piedmont Roofing provide honest advice.
Choosing a new roof should not be an overwhelming decision, but it often is for so many homeowners and commercial property owners. After all, there are many different materials on the market, each with its own set of pros and cons.
What is the best roof for your property? If you find yourself stuck between two strong contenders, like rubber and metal, this article will help you feel confident in the roof you finally choose.
Rubber Roof vs Metal Roof: What’s the Difference?
Both a rubber roof and a metal roof will serve your structure well. Yet they are two very different options. When weighing a rubber roof vs metal roof, the key differences often come down to slope, durability, and budget.
A rubber roof is a flexible, waterproof material that is generally used on low-slope or flat roofs. Sometimes referred to as TPO, EPDM, or modified bitumen, it is durable and easy to install. What’s more, it is great at keeping moisture at bay.
On the other hand, metal roofing is ideal for pitched roofs, though it may be found on low-slope or flat roofs with some extra care. These can be made of different metals like aluminum, steel, copper, and zinc.
Each option has a solid reputation for standing the test of time, but there is no denying that they are very different. As roofing professionals, we know that the best choice depends on your property’s unique needs, budget, and long-term goals, so we take the time to walk through those factors with you before recommending a solution.
Rubber Roofing: The Pros and Cons
Rubber roofing comes with some amazing qualities that set it apart from others, but it does have its limitations. First, let’s take a look at why this could be your best choice.
Does your home or commercial building have a flatter profile? For flat roofs, the rubber roof vs metal roof debate often ends quickly, as rubber offers better waterproofing for low-slope designs. Although not ideal for steep slopes, a rubber roof forms a water-tight seal that reduces your risk of water infiltration. It installs quickly, which means minimal interruptions to get it up and going. And, it can last upwards of 20 to 30 years!
Rubber roofing is lightweight and typically comes with a lower installation cost than metal. This can make it a great choice for older buildings or those on a budget.
The cons? A rubber roof may provide the functionality of a roof well, but it doesn’t necessarily enhance the structure’s appearance. Thankfully, because it is used primarily on flat roofs, its lack of appeal is not as noticeable.
Rubber can be vulnerable over time. It can be torn or punctured if tree branches, hail, or other debris hit it hard enough.
Metal Roofing: The Pros and Cons
Roofs of metal are growing in popularity atop residences and businesses alike. And for good reason, since they offer both functionality and aesthetics. They even come in different styles and colors to match any architectural style.
If your decision to buy a rubber roof vs metal roof, you may lean toward metal if longevity and aesthetics are your top priorities. Metal roofing is extremely durable and can have a lifespan upwards of 40 to 70 years, depending on the material. Being resistant to wind, fire, and weather impact makes them a perfect solution in areas that have storms and inclement weather.
Metal doesn’t warp, crack, or rot, which means the upkeep is rather simple, with very little maintenance necessary. There isn’t much more to do than have it regularly inspected and ensure it is clear of debris.
As with anything in life, there are a few cons when it comes to metal roofs. For instance, they tend to have a higher cost upfront. And, although the metal may be tough, damage is possible. Things like hail or falling branches can leave dents and scratches on the surface, especially with softer metals like aluminum.
How to Decide Which Roof is Right For You?
Choosing between a rubber roof and a metal roof isn’t just about the material itself, but instead finding the right fit for your property. There are a few key factors that can help you navigate your roofing choices.
The Roof’s Slope
Property owners comparing a rubber roof vs metal roof should first look at slope, as this factor will strongly influence performance. Low-slope or flat roofs require a material that offers superior waterproofing, such as a rubber roof. A metal roof is often a better choice for a property that has a steep slope for water to slide off easily.
Local Climate
In Virginia’s varied weather, the rubber roof vs metal roof choice may depend on how each material handles humidity, snow, and storms. Metal roofs have durability throughout the seasons, while rubber roofing is a better option for moderate climates. Virginia experiences a mix of weather during the year. Summertime can be hot and humid, while the cold winter can bring some snow. Heavy rains, wind, and the occasional threat of a hurricane are all possible. Both metal and rubber can stand up to these, depending, again, on the roof’s slope.
Budget
When cost is the deciding factor in the rubber roof vs metal roof choice, rubber tends to be more affordable upfront. Many find this a great option if working with a tight budget. Metal roofing is a bigger investment, but it does come with a much longer lifespan with little upkeep.
Ready to Choose the Right Roof?
If you’re still unsure about the rubber roof vs metal roof decision, our Piedmont Roofing experts can walk you through the pros and cons for your property. Virginia’s heat, cold snaps, and storms mean that your roof has to make more than just an appearance; the material you choose matters.
At Piedmont Roofing, we bring decades of experience working within your local communities, helping homeowners and business owners make the right decision. We will help you find the perfect roof for your structure and your budget.
With a trusted expert on your side, you don’t have to guess. Contact us today for a consultation and free estimate.
